“The roof always looks good when the sun is shining—it’s only when it rains you realize you have leaks.” This wisdom from Intuit’s former CEO shaped how Vidya Peters, CEO of DataSnipper, approaches one of business leadership’s toughest challenges: spotting problems before they crater your bottom line.
As AI continues devouring jobs across every industry, a question emerges: if machines can replace repetitive work today, why not CEO roles tomorrow? After all, leadership seems like it could be reduced to data analysis, strategic frameworks, and process optimization—all things AI excels at.
But Peters reveals why exceptional CEOs remain irreplaceably human. “Understanding internal growth issues is more of an art than science,” she explains. “If it was a science, I would have a perfect dashboard for it.”
The real challenge? Growth is the ultimate smokescreen. As Peters puts it bluntly: “Growth hides poor talent, strategy, or processes.” While AI can crunch numbers and spot obvious patterns, it takes human intuition to detect the subtle signs of organizational decay beneath impressive revenue figures.
The Curiosity Factor: Hiring Beyond AI’s Playbook
Most companies still hire for specific skills rather than adaptability—ironically reinforced by algorithms that struggle to measure intangible qualities like curiosity or grit.
Peters takes a radically different approach: “Hire for curiosity, not for skills. You can learn the skills. I can never teach you curiosity.”
Her former MuleSoft CEO used a metaphor to assess candidates that she now also applies: “People need to decide whether they are a cruise ship or speedboat person. The speedboat is bumpy—you will probably get wet. But if you want smooth sailing by the pool, choose the cruise ship. Scale-ups are speedboats, not cruise ships.”
This philosophy matters more than ever in our job-hopping economy. Generation Z changes roles every 1.1 years on average, compared to 1.8 years for millennials and 2.8 years for Gen X. Peters refuses to accommodate this trend: “I don’t hire job hoppers. People who jump around yearly lack the necessary grit and resilience.”
Until DataSnipper grew too large, Peters personally interviewed every single employee. Why? Because hiring decisions represent her greatest influence on business success, and people shape organizational culture in ways no algorithm can predict.
Strategy Isn’t What You Say Once—It’s What You Repeat Forever
Our company, HumanDynamics’, research shows that growth failures often stem from a critical disconnect: leadership thinks employees understand the strategy, but they don’t. AI might excel at creating strategic frameworks, but it can’t solve the human problem of comprehension and buy-in.
Peters learned this lesson the hard way: “People confuse strategy with tactics. I established three strategic pillars three years ago. Through repetition, employees learn that the vision stays constant—only the tactics for achieving these pillars change.”
Her litmus test for effective communication? “When I’m sick of saying it, I know employees are grasping the strategy.”
The Human Radar: Detecting Problems Before Data Can
While formal reports lag behind reality, Peters employs distinctly human methods to spot trouble early—techniques no AI system could replicate:
She reads every single comment from DataSnipper’s Net Promoter Score surveys, looking for patterns human eyes catch but algorithms miss. “This allows me to spot cracks before they appear anywhere else in the business.”
She becomes a secret customer unpredictably, testing response times and service quality firsthand. The timing matters—it’s irregular so employees don’t game the system.
At industry exhibitions, she personally visits DataSnipper’s booth to gauge genuine interest. If only students collecting freebies show up, it signals misallocated resources. “You need to be scrappy and thoughtful about every dollar invested.”
Perhaps most importantly, she schedules regular lunches with entry-level employees—the people closest to broken processes, missing tools, and cultural issues that never appear in executive dashboards.
The Irreplaceable Human Element
Peters has seemingly created a replicable rulebook: hire for curiosity and grit, communicate strategy relentlessly, remove obstacles proactively, and detect problems through human intelligence rather than dashboards.
But here’s the paradox—while her methods appear systematic, they depend entirely on human judgment, empathy, and contextual understanding that AI cannot replicate. Knowing when to trust your gut over data, how to read between the lines of feedback, and when to pivot tactics while maintaining strategic vision requires the kind of nuanced intelligence that remains human.
Beyond hiring well and communicating clearly, Peters defines her ultimate role as obstacle removal: “You’ve got great people and clear strategy—but are you removing the issues blocking their path to success?”
That question—and the human insight required to answer it—explains why great CEOs won’t be replaced by machines anytime soon. The art of leadership, it turns out, is irreducibly human.
link